I spoke with Kirk Williams, founder of ZATO Marketing, for an episode of PPC in the Trenches. I have followed Kirk’s work for years, including his book Ponderings of a PPC Professional, and wanted to hear how he is thinking about paid search, agency ownership and artificial intelligence.

We talked about serving smaller-budget clients, staying specialised and building an agency that fits your life. The question I kept coming back to was where human expertise belongs as more of the account work becomes automated, and whether adding more automation always makes an account better.

Watch on YouTube

Introduction

I have edited the conversation below for length and clarity, grouping related questions and answers by topic.

Jeremy: You were studying theology and working overnight before you got into marketing. How did you end up in paid search?

Kirk: I was pursuing my master’s in theology, working overnight and trying to keep up with the reading and writing. My wife worked during the day, so we barely saw each other.

Kirk: Eventually, I decided to take the next job that came along, and it happened to be in marketing. Someone asked whether I wanted to try this Google AdWords thing, and I loved learning it.

Kirk: The idea of connecting with people when they are telling you what they are interested in has always resonated with me. I started in-house at an e-commerce business, then went out on my own and eventually built a small team.

A smaller-budget package needs a different scope

Jeremy: You have continued serving smaller businesses as well as larger accounts. How have you made that work?

Kirk: I would not say we have completely figured it out. We have two different offerings, and the smaller-budget one is almost more like a product than a traditional agency service.

Kirk: We stripped out some of the things people usually expect from an agency. A lot of agency overhead comes from communication, so we are very clear that a lower fee does not include a full white-glove service.

Kirk: Some businesses just want their Google Ads managed so they can focus on running the business. That can be a good fit, but it is not what everyone wants, and we try to filter for that early.

Jeremy: I sometimes find smaller-budget accounts harder to manage. Larger businesses can have a longer timeline and understand how advertising fits into the bigger picture.

Kirk: It depends on the account, but I mostly agree. We recently had a new account where the client’s performance expectations did not align with how long it would take to break into the market.

KEY TAKEAWAY

A lower-cost Google Ads management package needs clearly defined limits on communication and service. Before signing up, the client and provider also need to agree on a realistic performance timeline, especially when the account is entering a competitive market for the first time.

Building an agency you actually like

Jeremy: What led you to write Stop the Scale: Building a Digital Agency You Actually Like?

Kirk: The book is a collection of thoughts and experiences from building a small agency I like. My TEDx talk explores a similar philosophy, but more broadly around redefining business success.

Kirk: I have tried to build within my own constraints, personality and values. Other people may be comfortable working more hours, but I have a family and six children, and those things matter to how I approach growth.

Jeremy: Part of why I keep things small is concern about quality. I worry that if I am not watching the work myself, something will get missed.

Kirk: Finding the right person and matching them with the right job can help. There are areas where the right team member can go beyond what you would have done yourself.

Kirk: There are also non-negotiables. If the way a prospective client talks about treating other people tells me I will not be able to trust them, we will walk away.

Kirk: That has affected how quickly we can grow. But there are opportunities I would rather lose than accept.

Jeremy: You are also quite self-reflective about leadership. Does that ever hold you back?

Kirk: It can go too far into self-doubt, which is not helpful either. Sometimes you need to make the best decision you can with what you know, accept that it might not be right and work through it.

Specialisation comes with trade-offs

Jeremy: Why stay focused on Google Ads rather than offering more channels? Do you lose work to agencies that can bundle everything together?

Kirk: Yes, we have lost clients who were happy with us but decided they could save money by moving everything to one agency. We have also won clients specifically because they wanted a deep specialist.

Kirk: I have accepted that some businesses want a generalist and others want to assemble a team of specialists. Our positioning appeals to one group more than the other.

Kirk: We offered Meta services years ago, but it was a different platform and marketing mentality. I found I was turning down Google Ads opportunities because I did not have the bandwidth while working on the other service.

Kirk: We have offered simpler Meta support through a freelancer in our smaller-business program, with clear expectations. Building a deeper service would require investing in a specialist, and that investment would compete with what we could do on the Google side.

KEY TAKEAWAY

Adding another advertising channel requires time, expertise and investment that could otherwise strengthen an agency’s existing service. A specialist agency may lose clients who prefer a bundled provider while attracting clients who value deeper expertise in one channel.

I recognise that trade-off in my own business. I explore the client’s side of the decision in my guide to choosing between a full-service agency, specialists and an in-house team.

Keeping up with change can be tiring

Jeremy: What still excites you about paid search?

Kirk: I am not sure “excited” is the right word for where I am personally right now. I am a little tired because the industry changes so dramatically and so constantly.

Kirk: I compared it to running a diesel mechanic’s workshop and suddenly having everything switch to electric. The tools and skills you built around one kind of engine need to change.

Kirk: That is how some of these platform changes feel. But I am also happy to be where I am, and I get back to work.

Kirk: I still manage a couple of accounts to stay close to the work. Recently, I have also enjoyed refining ZATO and building tools that could help our team.

Artificial intelligence as research support for the expert

Jeremy: How are you thinking about using artificial intelligence inside ZATO?

Kirk: I think of it a bit like a first-year law clerk doing research for the trial lawyer. The research matters, but the lawyer is still the person doing the main job.

Kirk: Our account managers and human experts remain central. We are humans talking to humans, with tools that help us do more.

Jeremy: What does that mean for juniors coming into the industry? Some of the work they would have learned through is now automated.

Kirk: We are all figuring this out, and we should not feel bad about that. Artificial intelligence is taking on some work we previously gave to juniors, but I am not convinced that means junior roles have simply disappeared for good.

Kirk: Even the economics could change. My conjecture is that as the costs of running and maintaining these tools develop, hiring and training someone could become more competitive than people assume.

Kirk: I do not know that will happen. But I still think artificial intelligence is a tool that needs expertise to build it, manage it and check the inputs.

Kirk: My advice to juniors is to remain willing to put time and energy into learning paid search. You still need to know the subject.

KEY TAKEAWAY

Automation may change the tasks given to junior paid-search staff, but Kirk Williams does not see that as a reason to stop learning the fundamentals. Building and supervising useful artificial intelligence tools still requires people who understand the accounts, inputs and decisions involved.

I found that distinction useful because it gives the tools a defined job. My conversation on where automation fits into a small business also looks at the importance of understanding the work before choosing the technology.

Could account-management agents over-optimise?

Jeremy: What is your prediction for the next couple of years?

Kirk: I think some third-party artificial intelligence agents may be less significant in account management than people expect. More intelligent automation is being built into the advertising platforms themselves.

Kirk: A third-party tool may then sit on top and make the kinds of changes people have traditionally made, but at much greater scale. My concern is that some of those changes could become unnecessary, or work against what the platform is doing.

Kirk: I have been increasingly impressed by Performance Max finding people through queries I would not necessarily have chosen myself. Those queries may make sense when combined with other signals available to Google.

Kirk: So I have a theory that some execution-focused agents could end up over-optimising. They might make changes for the sake of making changes rather than improving the account.

KEY TAKEAWAY

Kirk Williams’s concern is that third-party artificial intelligence agents could make unnecessary account changes at scale or interfere with the advertising platform’s own automation. He presents over-optimisation as a risk to investigate, rather than a proven outcome for every account-management tool.

Jeremy: You are willing to change your mind when parts of the automation work. I have had that experience with AI Max too.

Kirk: Yes. Where I increasingly see value is helping our team understand the whole context of a client, so we can guide Google towards the right people.

Kirk: That could mean bringing in more business information, such as Shopify numbers and spending across other marketing channels, rather than looking only at the advertising account.

Jeremy: Product profit matters too. You can have a high return on ad spend and still have a very thin margin.

Why Merchant Center deserves more attention

Jeremy: What do you think about the changes in Google Shopping and Merchant Center?

Kirk: I like the developments. I expect people working in e-commerce will need to become more knowledgeable about Google Merchant Center.

Kirk: My expectation is that more product-feed attributes will contribute to artificial intelligence-driven search and conversations. Merchant Center and the feed could become increasingly important for e-commerce stores.

KEY TAKEAWAY

Kirk Williams expects Google Merchant Center expertise and product-feed information to become more important as Google develops artificial intelligence-driven shopping experiences. His advice is for e-commerce marketers to deepen their understanding of product data rather than focus only on campaign settings.

Key Takeaways

I came away with a few things to keep thinking about:

  • I would define the service a smaller-budget client is buying, including communication, scope and the time needed to test the market.
  • I would judge an agency’s growth against the work, team and client relationships I want, while watching that caution does not turn into indecision.
  • I would assess automation by whether it helps the account, rather than by how many changes it can make.
  • I would use tools to understand more of the client’s business context, including product margins and activity beyond the advertising platform.

Learn more at ZATO Marketing, and connect with Kirk Williams on LinkedIn. You can also find him on Instagram, Facebook and X.

This conversation was recorded for PPC in the Trenches with Jeremy Yang. You can watch the full episode on YouTube.